For a decade, the 1.5 degree Celsius warming limit served as the unquestioned pole star of global climate policy. It was a firm guideline to which the world's nations committed in the Paris Agreement in an effort to avoid the worst consequences of warming. The planet. However, at this year's COP31 global climate conference in Antalya, Turkey, diplomatic mechanisms found themselves in an unprecedented crisis. These are the first ministerial talks since the United Nations officially announced in September that the planet has already warmed by about 1.4°C compared to the pre-industrial era and exceeding the most ambitious limit of 1.5°C is imminent and inevitable.
Halfway through the negotiations in Turkey, the international community is deeply uncertain about how to take this message. While vulnerable island states refuse to abandon the goal, viewing it as a matter of their own survival, powerful negotiating blocs of emerging economies are looking for an opportunity to break away from the formal commitment to the limit.
The existential imperative of island nations and the Australian Summary
For countries on the front lines of the climate crisis, losing the 1.5°C target is not just a change in diplomatic language, but a direct threat to their physical existence. Pacific island nations threatened by rising sea levels have openly warned that any warming beyond that level poses an existential risk. Palau President Surangel Whipps Jr. has made it clear that 1.5°C was never just an „abstract goal.“.
This stance is reflected in the official negotiating documents. According to a summary of positions released by Australia, the conference’s chair, several nations are pushing for the final COP31 agreement to explicitly confirm that 1.5°C remains „the right goal.“ At the same time, these nations are pushing for language on returning to 1.5°C „as soon as possible“ and insisting that global temperatures „can still be“ reduced once the threshold is inevitably crossed.
Behind the scenes, many negotiators are skeptical of such a trajectory, but they are reluctant to give up on the goal. Among delegates, there is a belief that this limit is necessary to maintain pressure to reduce planet-warming greenhouse gas emissions as quickly as possible.
Geopolitical divide and funding disputes
In stark contrast to the vulnerable states, efforts to backtrack are taking shape behind closed doors. Observers of the ongoing negotiations say several delegations are seeking an opportunity to get out of the 1.5°C commitment. This approach is being pushed in particular by two influential blocs of emerging economies: the Arab Group and the Lesser-Like-Minded Developing Countries (LMDCs), which include countries such as Saudi Arabia and India.
Western officials are warning against such developments. One high-ranking delegate from a Western country openly warned of a „potential setback“ in global climate action if these efforts at COP31 were to succeed.
But the emerging economies’ stance is based on pragmatic concerns about uneven burden-sharing. As Jasper Inventor, head of the Greenpeace delegation in Antalya, pointed out, developing countries fear that a stronger reference to 1.5°C in the final agreement will result in greater pressure to reduce emissions without providing them with corresponding additional financial assistance.
This diplomatic resistance was also reflected in the push to reject the so-called „grey literature“ in the list of negotiating priorities. This indirect reference was seen as an attack on the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), which in September published a study on scenarios for exceeding the temperature threshold and the possibilities of reducing global temperatures back to 1.5°C by 2100.
| Negotiation block / Actor | Representatives | Attitude towards 1.5°C | Key arguments and motivation |
| Vulnerable island states | Palau (Surangel Whipps Jr.) | Strictly maintaining the goal | The existential threat of rising sea levels; the goal is not abstract. |
| COP31 Presidency | Australia | Enforcing formulations about returning below the threshold | Confirmation that 1.5°C remains the right target and temperatures can be reduced. |
| Emerging economies | Arab Group, LMDC (Saudi Arabia, India) | Trying to leave the limit | Concerns about pressure to reduce emissions without additional financial assistance. |
| UN leadership and agencies | António Guterres, UNEP | Minimizing the length and extent of the overrun | Efforts to maintain the Paris Agreement framework and modeling a return to 2100. |
The scientific reality of exceedance scenarios and technological limits
Under the Paris Agreement, nearly two hundred countries agreed to keep warming „well below“ 2°C and to pursue efforts to limit it to 1.5°C. As scientific evidence mounts, the lower limit has taken on new urgency. Scientists warn that above 1.5°C, the risks rise sharply – from more severe flooding and devastating heatwaves to irreversible changes to the planet, such as the permanent loss of coral reefs.
Outgoing UN Secretary-General António Guterres, who spent a decade in office uniting states behind the 1.5°C target, reminded participants in Antalya that any overshoot must be „as small as possible and for as short a time as possible.“.
But there are serious doubts about the feasibility of such a return. Climatologist Pierre Friedlingstein of the University of Exeter, lead author of the Global Carbon Budget study, warned that the idea of reducing temperatures back to 1.5°C is uncertain. It requires not only a sharp drop in emissions, but also removing carbon from the atmosphere through natural means – planting trees and restoring wetlands – and new technologies. Friedlingstein stressed that these new technologies would need to be deployed massively on an enormous scale over decades. As he summed up, it is not utopia, but it is an „extraordinarily ambitious“ plan.
The COP31 summit is thus facing a fundamental decision halfway through its course: how to maintain the ambitions of the Paris Agreement without the international community turning a blind eye to the physical reality of the warming already underway. JRi&CO2AI



